Entering the 2024 season, boys' Varsity baseball have been on a roll. The Phoenix have won three consecutive FSL Championships having gone undefeated in league play (30-0) during that span. They have have been outstanding in non-league play, too, with three consecutive 20-win seasons, the first three 20-win seasons in School history. For the past 10 years, the team has been guided by Head Coach Jon Rubin ‘83, who pitched at Penn and later played overseas in Australia. Since 2014, the Phoenix have seen numerous players advance to the next level, including Rubin’s son Bryan '14, who had a standout career at Vassar and has gone on to play professionally in Germany, Guatemala, and Salem, Oregon. Other FCS alum collegiate baseball players include:

Hayden Gruber '14 - Tufts
Ardon Fryer '15 - Orange Coast
Alec Andrews '17 - Muhlenberg, Post University
Ben Kollender '19 - Muhlenberg
Leo Burman '20 - York
Justin Rubin '21 - Virginia/Pepperdine
Jack Donahoe '21 - Misericordia
Sammy Burman '22 - Hofstra/Catholic U
Luke Buscaglia '22 - UMBC
Caden Carlin '22 - Monmouth
Johnny Fitzpatrick '22 - West Chester/Immaculata
Jon Aman '22 - Widener
Derek Francis '22 - Alvernia
Dylan Posencheg '22 - Dickinson
Julian Abreu '23 - Marist
Darius Adkins '23 - St Joes
Alejandro Flores '23 - Penn State - Harrisburg
Lucca Frattone '23 - Wesleyan